By Christina Lyon

The most sensitive skin on your body also happens to be the spot most people notice first: your eyes. This can be problematic for women over 40 who commonly experience puffiness, dark circles, bags, fine lines, and wrinkles. What can you do?

Rather than using whatever face moisturizer is on the counter on the delicate eye area, you’ll want a devoted anti-aging eye cream that tackles your specific needs. But scouring the internet for the perfect eye cream is daunting! 

Well, ladies, we researched so that you don’t have to!

We’ve learned the science, browsed dermatologist recommendations, and read customer reviews. Here’s our list of the best anti-aging eye creams for 2022!

Eye Cream Pricing Key

We’ve outlined our top picks by focus and price because we believe skin care can be effective and affordable. Every product on our list is under $100, available from Amazon, and clinically-trusted. Find the right pick from our curated list of the best anti aging eye creams in 2022 by price range.

• Budget-friendly products are less than $30.
• Middle-range products are $30-$60
• Splurge products are $60-$100

Let’s jump right in!

Best Overall Anti-Aging Eye Creams in 2022

Whether you need to depuff, smooth out wrinkles and fine lines, or brighten dark circles, below are our top recommendations for the overall best anti-aging eye creams (as of 2022) for every budget. 

Budget-Friendly

Multi Correxion 5 in 1 Eye Cream by RoC – $19.98
This powerhouse cream tackles the problems most women over 40 encounter: it brightens dark circles, depuffs eye bags, and increases firmness around the eyes by 19%. And for this price, it’s a steal. 

Real review: “I’m 44 years old… It works great! I noticed a difference within a few days!”

Middle-Range

Origins A Perfect World SPF 20 Age-Defense Eye Cream by Origins – $32.95
This age-defense eye cream boosts hydration and brightens the eyes with natural antioxidants like white tea. Plus, it has SPF-20, so you can apply in the morning and go about your day with confidence and radiant eyes — sans irritation. 

Real review: “It improved the wrinkles and appearance of my eyes, so I highly recommend. ALSO: No more burnt lids!​​

Splurge

Colorescience Total Eye 3-in-1 Renewal Therapy – $69
We can justify the splurge because this anti-aging concealer eye cream has the whole package: it reduces wrinkles, brightens dark circles, de-puffs baggy eyes, has SPF 35, and concealer! All this is done with plant-based ingredients including a plant-derived hyaluronic acid. Plus, we love the easy applicator tip. 

Real review: “I’m in my 60’s… I find this product is a great moisturizing base that reduces the look of red skin, provides good sunscreen, and may actually be giving some improvement to the texture of my lids.”

Best All-Natural Eye Creams 

Budget-Friendly

Weleda Awakening Eye Cream – $24.62
An eye-cream you can buy at Target that’s supported by dermatologists, free of chemical gunk, and actually works? Yes, please! If you have sensitive skin, this silky, light, fragrance-free, all-natural eye cream uses gentle ingredients like jojoba seed oil, sesame seed oil, shea butter, pomegranate seed oil, and argan oil to smooth and hydrate. 

Real review: “How did I live without this before now? I use it morning and night and have noticed a difference in how smooth my under eye area looks. I definitely look better with less wrinkling there. It seems to have plumped up my skin a little bit!” 

Middle-Range

REN Clean Skincare Keep Young And Beautiful Firm And Lift Eye Cream – $44
Proving you don’t need chemicals and toxins to give your eyes the boost they need, this ultra-firming, hydrating eye cream uses natural ingredients like rosehip and shea butter to minimize wrinkles and target crow’s feet. All around, it’s a great natural eye cream specifically designed for women over 40.

Real review: “I’ve used this for years; it’s the best product I ever put around my eyes. Immediate radiance and a fresh look. Even within a week, wrinkles and fine lines became less noticeable, and with regular use, they seemed almost invisible.” 

Splurge

Shaba Complex firming eye serum by Drunk Elephant – $91.99
This all natural eye cream is made in the USA and combats dark circles and puffiness. A powerhouse cocktail of black tea, zinc oxide, thermal mud, marula oil, and copper peptides delivers an au naturale solution!

Real review: “This eye cream is extremely moisturizing, and a little goes a long way. Highly recommend.”

Best Eye-Creams For Brightening Dark Circles 

Budget-Friendly

Olay Vitamin C Brightening Eye Cream – $18.97
Who has time for dark, puffy eyes? We love this drugstore eye cream for its brightening agents like Vitamin B3 & C and caffeine. The ingredients safely target delicate eye skin to blend discoloration and brighten dark circles. This drug-store find packs a punch! 

​Real review: “I have only been using it twice a day for about four days; it has already made a difference in the darkness and puffiness around my eyes.”

Middle-Range

It Cosmetics Confidence In An Eye Cream – $30
Often, the root of dark circles is a lack of hydration. We love this ultra-creamy eye cream packed with moisturizing avocado, squalane, hyaluronic acid, niacinamide, and ceramides that plump and brighten dark eyes. 

Real review: “Skincare junkie approved. Best product I’ve ever used. It depuffs and moisturizes an area that is delicate and requires a light touch. No tingling or stinging.” 

Runner up: EltaMD Renew Eye Gel for Dark Circles. $56.

Splurge

SkinCeuticals AGE Eye Complex – $90
With balmy, light-reflecting mineral pigments, you know this brightening eye cream is going to lift, illuminate, and hydrate. While the price lands on the splurge scale, it’s money well spent considering the moisturizing and anti-aging properties that also combat puffiness and crow’s feet. 

Real review: “I’ve been using this for over a year now. When I ran out recently, I definitely noticed a difference. My eyes got darker, and I could see fine lines more. I ordered more, and it’s working again! Love it. I’m 50, by the way, and have hereditary dark eye circles.”

Top Picks for Fine Lines and Crow’s Feet

Budget-Friendly

SkinActive Ultra-Lift Anti-Wrinkle Eye Cream – $14.49
This anti-aging eye cream contains rich antioxidants and Vitamin A to reduce fine lines, target crow’s feet, and improve elasticity — all for under 15 bucks! 

Real review: “I am 41 and never really used an eye cream… I woke up this morning, and my puffy, old, dark, terrible looking eyes have improved by like 90% — this product is a huge lifesaver.”

Runner up: Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Eye Cream. $16.68. Targets fine lines and stubborn crow’s feet with mega hydration.

Middle-Range

Dermalogica Intensive Eye Repair – $59
If you have fine lines, dehydrated and sensitive skin, this intensive eye cream reduces fine lines caused by dehydration and infuses skin with rich vitamins and grape seed extract. 

Real review: “I buy this product all the time. I have used it for 35 years. I am 70 and just now am seeing lines around my eyes. Great brand, great product.”

Splurge

Eminence Organic Snow Mushroom Moisture Cloud Eye Cream – $78
If you’re struggling with crow’s feet, bathe your skin in this creamy, rich, nourishing moisture cloud that targets deep lines.

Best For Hydrating Dry Skin 

Budget-Friendly

TULA Probiotic Skin Care Glow & Get It Cooling & Brightening Eye Balm – $28
Lack of hydration causes a slew of skin problems, including cracking, brittle, and drooping eye skin. To the rescue is this ultra-nourishing eye balm stick that replenishes dry skin, minimizes dark circles, and gives a dewy, moisturized glow. Perfect for a morning brightening or mid-day boost. 

Real review: “I have insomnia and have the darkest and puffiest under eyes ever; nothing else has really worked, but this reduces the dark circles, and the cooling element really reduces the puffiness for me.”

Middle-Range

Burt’s Bees Intense Hydration Eye Cream, Moisturizing Eye Treatment – $44.95
The delicate skin around the eyes is fragile and sensitive. Too much moisture causes eye-burn, but this anti-aging, all-natural eye cream strikes the perfect balance to beat dryness. Plus, it’s free of all the known allergens like parabens and phthalates. That’s why Burt’s Bees is always a top fave!

Real review: “I’ve only used this for two days, and already the dry patches are healing! No irritation, no fogginess. It’s even making the fine lines disappear.”

Splurge

Do Not Age Triple Peptide Eye Cream – $80
When the second ingredient is shea butter, you know you’re in for a moisture bath! Add jojoba seed oil, grapefruit extract, and lavender oil, and you get a rich, creamy, nourishing formula to restore dry cracks, puffiness, and dark circles.

Real review: “I really love this eye cream; it really helped with my dark circle and wrinkles under my eye. My eyes look vibrant all day.”

Top Pick for Sensitive Skin

Budget-Friendly

Bioderma – Sensibio Eye Contour Gel – $19.90
We love this light, moisturizing formula designed to provide hydration without overwhelming sensitive skin. Plus, it visibly reduces fine lines! 

Real review: “This moisturizer works so well for my very, very sensitive skin. I’ve been using sensitive skin products for years, and this is the best that I’ve found.”

Middle-Range

Kiehl’s Creamy Eye Treatment with Avocado – $51
With natural ingredients like avocado oil and beta carotene, this nourishing eye treatment is perfect for the sensitive skin around the eyes.

Real review: “Definitely recommend this product. It saved my under eyes from being dry with literally two applications.”

Best For DePuffing and Firming the Eye Area

Budget-Friendly

Lift & Luminate Triple Action Eye Cream – $19.99
If lifting and firming is what you need, this depuffing eye cream delivers. Specifically designed to ward off the signs of aging while reducing the appearance of fine lines, your skin will be tighter and more evenly colored with this fast-acting formula. 

Real review: “It’s super silky and absorbs into the skin very well. It didn’t take long to notice some improvement of color correction and smoothing out the fine lines around my mouth and eyes.”

Middle-Range

Dermalogica Multivitamin Power Firm – $65
This Age Smart™ serum contains a potent blend of essential oils like green tea, grape, and safflower to repair loose, puffy skin and rebuild elasticity with silicones and red seaweed extract. The result? Firmer, more resilient skin! 

Real review: “I’ve been using the Multivitamin Power Firm around my eyes for about ten years. I’m 61, but everyone thinks I’m in my early 50s.”

Splurge

Retinol Youth Renewal Eye Serum – $85
If you have slack skin around the eyes, this collagen-boosting retinol formula goes to work to firm, tighten, and depuff better than its competition. And there’s clinical research to support: in the Beauty Lab test, firmness improved by 33%! 

Real review: “This product took my sagging/thin under eyes and firmed the area beautifully.”

For Beautiful Eyes… 

Audrey Hepburn said, “For beautiful eyes, look for the good in others… and keep a good eye cream within arm’s reach!” Okay, we couldn’t resist adding that last part!

If bright, healthy eyes are on your radar, you now have one of the best anti-aging eye creams from 2022 for your skin type to add to your skincare routine. We’ll conclude with these final tips:

• Apply your new product consistently to yield the best results. 
• Follow directions to ensure you don’t overuse the cream and irritate your skin.
• Don’t be afraid to try a few products until you find the perfect match!

Now you’re ready to embrace the world with bright, firm, and radiant eyes!

Next, read how to take your hydrated base to a flawless finish with our favorite undereye concealers.

Shop This Post